Pennsylvania Supreme Court to Review Enforceability of Venue-Selection Clauses in Medical Malpractice Cases

Healthcare Practice Client Alert
Joshua Gajer and Veronica R. Hogan
11.18.26

Venue in medical malpractice cases has been a hotly litigated issue since the Pennsylvania Supreme Court abrogated the special venue rule applicable to such cases in 2023. Since that time, plaintiffs have been allowed to bring medical malpractice suits in any county where a corporate healthcare defendant “regularly conducts business.” In response to the rule change, many healthcare corporations have begun including venue selection agreements in their admission paperwork requiring patients to bring any claim for malpractice in the county where the care was rendered. Last year, in Somerlot v. Jung, the Superior Court held that such venue selection clauses were valid and enforceable.

On September 14, 2026, the Supreme Court granted Plaintiffs’ Petition for Allowance of Appeal in Somerlot to consider (1) whether a venue selection clause between a plaintiff and some but not all defendants in a multidefendant joint and several liability action controlled over Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1006(c)’s language that venue as to any one defendant establishes proper venue as to all defendants; (2) under the facts of this particular case, whether the selection clause was sufficiently reasonable to be enforced; and (3) whether it was appropriate to include the venue selection agreement in a surgical consent form?

This case is being closely watched by medical malpractice plaintiff and defense attorneys throughout the Commonwealth because a decision in favor of the plaintiffs has the potential to upend years of legal precedent and remove another avenue healthcare providers have to limit lawsuits to the counties where their care was rendered. As it stands, there has been a flood of medical malpractice litigation in Philadelphia since the 2023 venue rule change. A Supreme Court decision overruling Somerlot is likely only to further encourage that trend. Additionally, it may have implications for a range of venue selection agreements in all manners of other cases.   

If you have questions about this update or would like additional information, please contact a member of the Healthcare Practice, or the authors: Joshua Gajer, Partner (gajerj@whiteandwilliams.com, or 215.864.6837), or Veronica R. Hogan, Associate (hoganv@whiteandwilliams.com, or 215.864.7196). 

This correspondence should not be construed as legal advice or legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances. The contents are intended for general informational purposes only and you are urged to consult a lawyer concerning your own situation and legal questions.

PRACTICE AREAS

Practice Areas

KEY ATTORNEYS

Jump to Page

By using this site, you agree to our updated Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.